If a paper is sent out for evaluation, we normally select 3 external reviewers including (if appropriate) one reviewer suggested by the authors. Meaning of ‘Awaiting Editor Assignment’ This means that your manuscript has cleared the admin check, that is, it was found matching the journal’s scope and also adhering to the journal’s guidelines, apart from a cursory check of the novelty and quality of the study. Jul 24, 2020 · My manuscript submission status in ManuscriptCentral changed from ‘Awaiting Referee Assignment’ to ‘Under Review’ after 15 days of submission. Jul 12, 2022 · The statuses on submission portals change based on the journal's processes in real-time. Should I be worried? Is there anything I can do to accelerate this process? The problem is, I am planning to submit an adapted version of the manuscript as a book chapter. Improve this answer. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. When you have submitted your paper or case study, up to three experts in the field will review it to provide validation, quality control and added value to you in the form of constructive feedback. At first, the status showed "awaiting AE recommendation". Jul 29, 2023 · Raremetals has also experienced an increase in its impact factor during these past two years, taking advantage of this trend. "awaiting other reviewer" not only signifies a stage in the review process where one reviewer has Dec 5, 2017 · I have submitted a paper to a very reputed publication of electrical engineering via ScholarOne. Yes, it could be rejected. Once enough reviewers have been selected, the manuscript will move on to the next stage. Feb 17, 2021 · No revisions because it is already "Awaiting AE recommendation". The status of my paper changed from "Awaiting AE assignment" to "Under Review" directly. Dec 12, 2019 · I submitted my manuscript to a journal. This status is rather uncommon. However, I just noticed that the status of my revised manuscript Apr 1, 2019 · 1 Answer to this question. This means they only check whether a paper has sufficient reviewers every K month(s). If it is not a desk reject, then it will surely go to the external peer-reviewers for review. " Sep 15, 2021 · 1 Answer to this question. Since the status is also showing "ADM" (which means "admin") my guess is that the manuscript is still in the admin check phase. 21 Awaiting Reviewer Scores 7. Search for the manuscript by ID, title, or author name using the Quick Search feature. answered Mar 29, 2018 at 7:04. I suppose that in most cases of minor revision, the revised manuscript will only be reviewed by the ADM or associate editor. 21 Awaiting AE Recommendation 7. Then a few days later it switched back to "Awaiting referee assignment" again. the status of “awaiting reviewer assignment” just last for less than one day, and on the same day, the status was changed to “awaiting reviewer scores”. The status has not changed to ‘Under review’. In Covidence, the status "awaiting other reviewer" means that a reference has been voted on by one reviewer, but a second vote is required before the reference can be moved to the next stage in the review process. This means that while the manuscript cleared the desk screening and was deemed good to go for peer review, the journal is finding it somewhat challenging to identify the right peer reviewers for your paper. There is a great hope that the journal's impact factor will surpass 10 in the coming years. Even if not, they should be able to inform you about the reason for the seeming delay. Answer: Once you submit your manuscript, the exact course of the peer review process depends on the specific journal that you have submitted to. I didnt see the "under review Jul 31, 2021 · As for your question about the “awaiting reviewer selection” status, please note that this status indicates that the journal editor is looking for peer reviewers for your paper, which means that your manuscript has cleared desk screening (congratulations!). The EiC gives the final verdict based on the AE's recommendation. However, it is the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief to deal with such delays. The minimum would be either two or three depending on the publication but the associate editor might have sent a few more invitations around. Awaiting Admin Processing: Your submission is waiting for initial review by the editorial office. If the evaluations are negative, the paper is normally rejected. Related reading: What does a status change from "Awaiting reviewer score" back to "Awaiting reviewer assignment" mean? Sep 5, 2022 · Awaiting Reviewer Assignment means the journal editor has started reaching out to potential reviewers for your manuscript. Let’s take them one by one. It it is desk reject, then reviewer means the editor herself. Does it mean that is under the review of editorial office? Could it change from Awaiting AE assignment to Under Review directly without AE being assigned ? Could Nov 30, 2020 · The manuscript being stuck at Awaiting Reviewer Assignment for a month is not uncommon. " At this stage, the EA goes through the paper and Sep 20, 2017 · It typically means that the paper has been received, has been put in the work queue of the editor, but the editor has not assigned reviewers. So I thought it passed the associate editor's evaluation and now they were looking for reviewers. Also, one reviewer may send their comments on time or earlier, and the other(s) may take a while to get back. May 3, 2019 · The status "Editor assignment pending" means that your paper has still not been assigned to an editor. Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally. For your current submission, the status change you have described indicates that your manuscript had passed the admin check and the reviewer selection process had started. 20 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment 6. The journal peer review process. "Awaiting reviewers reply" means that your manuscript has been sent out for review. 21 Awaiting Reviewer Scores Awaiting Reviewer Invitation: At this stage, the Associate Editor should invite reviewers to evaluate the article, from those chosen in the previous step. In this case, it is possible that the editor is now busy and is unable to take on your manuscript at the moment, which is why the status shows Jun 16, 2020 · Coming to your query, what ‘Editorial assignment pending’ at this stage means is that your revised manuscript is awaiting a review by an associate editor (AE). There is no set time for this to take. 11 Awaiting AE Assignment 6. However, today, it changed back to Awaiting Referee Scores. I'm not sure what JM checklist refers to, but my guess is that Oct 30, 2023 · After 20 days, status has changed from "awaiting reviewer selection" to "awaiting reviewer assignment" and after 4 days, it has changed to "awaiting reviewer scores". For minor revisions, some editors might make a decision on their own, but they can send it out for peer review if they feel the need to. This is usually because of a scope mismatch, or in some cases, the novelty and/or quality of the research/paper not being The acronym ME most likely stands for "Managing Editor" or "Manuscript Editor", and so the message says that the paper is awaiting processing by this person. “Reader” in this case probably refers to an admin person who will read the Aug 31, 2019 · 1 Answer to this question. 一般在一周以内，看审稿人的回复速度； Verified Reviews - IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON COMMUNICATIONS. " Oct 24, 2018 · I just submitted a revised paper to ScholarOne (major revision). Under Review: This means Dec 19, 2019 · 1. Nov 5, 2019 · The status "Reviewers contacted" means that the editor has sent out review invitations to the requisite number of reviewers (usually 2 or 3). So, perhaps the AE believes they can check the manuscript on their own. 24 Awaiting EIC Decision 7. The status, "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" indicates that the preliminary checks have been completed and that the manuscript is now ready to be sent to the select reviewers We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Once the required number of reviewers accept the review invitation, the status changes to "Under review. So, even after one reviewer submits his report, the immediate change in status would be a reflection of that Mar 16, 2022 · Answer: Dear Author, Thank you for your question. I am not Jan 19, 2021 · Q: What does it mean if the status has been 'Awaiting EIC Decision' for the past 20 days? Detailed Question - After more than a year of passing through review > major review > review > minor revision > review, the status has been ‘Awaiting EIC decision’ for the past 20 days. If so, it seems to have gone from this decision to awaiting a decision by the Editor-in-Chief (EiC). Mar 25, 2016 · 1 Answer to this question. Anything is possible. This change has occurred Apr 27, 2017 · I recently submitted my first paper to a philosophy journal. Your account on the journal’s ScholarOne Manuscripts site may be created in one of two ways. Jul 1, 2017 · A reviewer refused to review the manuscript after some days (this is a very rare case), so the editor will send the manuscript to a new potential reviewer. If all the reviewers accept the invitations, the peer review process will start and the status will change to "Under review. It means that the AE has performed their initial check (as described in the previous point) and is looking for suitable peer reviewers. ’ All Answers (5) 'Awaiting decision' means the required reviews to make a decision were completed. Mar 28, 2015 · AE stands for "Associate Editor. May 30, 2020 · Coming to your present query, as we just indicated, this has been a slow change from ‘Awaiting Reviewer Assignment’ to ‘Under Review. Account Setup and Maintenance. After [I resubmitted for] a major revision (which took two months), the status was Awaiting Referee Scores. ’ But this could be because the associate editor (AE) may have had a challenge finding reviewers for your manuscript. I submitted a manuscript to a Sage Journal almost 50 days ago. This change has occurred Nov 24, 2021 · Thank you for your question. Feb 14, 2023 · I recently submitted a paper to a (not very selective) journal (Sage publications). So, one can’t really put a timeline to it. "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" means that the paper has been assigned the minimum amount of reviewers that the Associate Editor has set for the manuscript. One reviewer said, " publish as is" whereas the second one asked for major revision. "Awaiting EIC decision" means that the journal is waiting on a decision by the "Editor in Chief". Some journals may include account information along with the invitation to review. If that was the case for your paper, then a subsequent change to "Awaiting reviewer invitation" would mean that the editor is sending your paper for an additional review. It was perhaps a minor revision or not a very extensive major revision. The reviewer has accepted the invitation and the editor is waiting to receive reviewer comments. After one day of submission, status was ‘Awaiting Decision’; but now after 10 days, status change into ‘Awaiting reviewer selection’. Since the reviews have come in, the AE should ideally not take Mar 13, 2020 · What these statuses could mean is that the AE has had a look at your manuscript and has made a tentative decision on it. When the search results appear, select “View Details” in the “Take Action” drop down menu. The manuscript awaiting the assignment of an editor for more than two-and-half months is both a bit long and unusual. It depends on whether the editor invites new reviewers. Oct 9, 2018 · Generally speaking, the status "Awaiting a reviewer reply" could mean either of two things: 1. The status “'Awaiting AE evaluation'” means that that the peer review has been completed and now the Assigned Editor (AE) will consider the feedback provided by the peer reviewers and arrives at a decision. Oct 24, 2020 · A direct change after submission (or after the initial admin check) to ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation’ typically means that the Associate Editor (AE) has had a look at the paper and decided not to send it for review. But after three days of this change, suddenly, the status changed back to ‘Awaiting Referee Assignment. Nov 16, 2015 · A plausible guess is that the editorial software uses "awaiting reviewer selection" to mean that the manuscript has been received but has not been sent to a reviewer. Foxing. Nov 19, 2020 · I submitted an article to a ScholarOne journal. However, after a few days, I got a desk reject notification. 2022/10/13 submit, Awaiting AE Assignment 2022/10/17 Status: Awaiting Reviewer Selection 2022/11/4 Status: Under review 2023/2/12 Status: Major Revision 2023/3/27 Major revision Explore Zhihu's column for a platform that allows users to write and express themselves freely. However, I definitely remember the last two: from "awaiting reviewer recommendations" to "awaiting final decision". 3. Generally, 2-3 peer reviewers are assigned to a paper. You will see little messages like ‘awaiting editorial approval’, ‘awaiting reviewer scores’, ‘awaiting editorial board comments’ and It means nothing. The status "Awaiting AE assignment" implies that an editor will be assigned to handle the correspondence of your submitted manuscript. The following are the most common decisions that are made: Hope this answers your question. Answer: It is quite normal for a revised paper to be reviewed once again. . Dec 7, 2018 · 1 Answer to this question. Understand the journal and case study peer review process and read our tips for revising your submission. After a week of submission, the status changed to "awaiting reviewer selections". Once the completed reviews come in, the Associate Editor (AE) evaluates them and gives his recommendation to the EiC. The editor in chief may not just 'accept' or 'reject' the manuscript. This is when the status changed to "EA: [name]. Awaiting EIC decision must have appeared after the first status while you did not check your status! It Appearing after short interval of awaiting reviewer assignment clearly means that associate editors have advised against it! Now the EIC has to make decision. A review invitation has been sent out but the reviewer has not yet accepted it. Dec 12, 2019 · I submitted my manuscript to a journal. “Awaiting SE Recommendation” means that it went to a Section Editor (SE) of the journal for checking the match with that section of the journal. Awaiting Editor Assignment: Your article has passed initial quality checks by the Editorial Production Assistant and is in the process of being assigned to an appropriate Editor who will evaluate your article for scope, quality, and fit for the journal. t backed up) waiting to be sent to some reviews. That could be because the system requires four reviewers, but the editor has only gotten the Sociologist039. You can send a request for an update at any time. These status should not be taken seriously. There is no oracle for such things. Aug 21, 2023 · 2. This is probably a duplicate, but I won't mark it as such since my vote would be definitive. Since it has been about a month since the status “Awaiting a reviewer Sep 15, 2020 · Quick change to Awaiting Reviewer Selection While this typically means that the manuscript is awaiting peer review, because the status changed so quickly after submission, this probably refers to the internal review, which is about aspects such as a match with the journal’s scope, the quality of the writing/presentation, and the research at a Jan 31, 2024 · On the other hand, the status "Awaiting reviewer scores" means that the paper is under review. So, please give me advice. Also known as: with reviewers, with referees, under review, awaiting referee assignment, awaiting referee reports, awaiting reviewer scores (ScholarOne), reviewers assigned, manuscript assigned to peer-reviewer/s (NPG) The initial selection of referees is usually comprised in the previous step. Awaiting Reviewer Assignment: Indicates that invitations have already been sent to reviewers but that reviewers have not yet responded. In general, revised submissions are assigned to the same editor who was handling it the first time. 2. Advertisement. Awaiting Editor Assignment: Multiple editors may be assigned to your submission, depending on the journal's workflow. But an average of 30 days tells you little about the distribution of actual times. As per my understanding, the status should be Awaiting EIC Decision. " Once the EA started checking the manuscript, the status changed to "Awaiting ED Assignment. ' It has been a month now, but the status has not changed. You can check the acceptance percentage Nov 1, 2019 · The editors are reading it and checking their reviewer list. In this stage, the editor identifies a few reviewers for your paper and sends out email invitations to them. What does this mean? Apr 21, 2020 · You have three queries. Jul 4, 2020 · I submitted my manuscript five weeks ago, and in a week, the status appeared as 'Awaiting Reviewer Selection. As you may know, peer review can take a while, as peer reviewers do this along with their other work. Share. I am afraid that after this long period, the editor will reject the manuscript. (The journal I submitted to allows it to be reprinted by Nov 15, 2023 · Updated on November 15, 2023. To get a second opinion, they have referred the manuscript both to the ME and to the peer reviewers. After about a month, the status switched from "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" to "Awaiting recommendation". You'll see this status at the start and end of the review cycle. thanks a lot. 是的，"awaiting reviewer assignment" 的意思是论文已经进行了小修并等待分配审稿人。. A few days ago, it was changed to "awaiting reviewer selection". It’s more common to have a challenge finding peer reviewers, unless with this journal or for this paper, the review is to be done internally. Should I Jun 27, 2018 · Generally, the status changes to "Awaiting ED recommendations" once peer review for the paper is done and the reviewer comments have come in. If the evaluations require major revisions and the paper has been submitted as a Research Note, it is likely to Jul 15, 2019 · 1 Answer to this question. 这意味着编辑团队已经收到您修订后的论文，并正在进行审稿人的分配工作。. Oct 31, 2017 · Initially, once your paper was submitted, the status showed "Admin not assigned. Answer: Thank you for your question! The status "Awaiting Referee Report" implies that the reviewers are already assigned and review work is in-progress. Or (in one system I know of), that the editor has not assigned the necessary number of reviewers. Nov 22, 2021 · Thank you for your question. One reason why this stage is taking long could be that the journal editor is having Jan 21, 2020 · Awaiting Editor Assignment: While this typically means that the manuscript is awaiting assignment to an AE, in this case, it probably means it is awaiting assignment to a peer reviewer. I submitted the revision almost 2 months back. There could be many reasons for a delay, including not sending too many papers to one editor and needing to find another who is suitable. In my opinion, ED in ScholarOne refers to Editor and GE refers to Guest Editor. Sep 18, 2020 · I have submitted a manuscript to a pediatrics-related journal. My manuscript had earlier gone through English proofreading by a professional vendor. Answer: It is difficult to estimate how much longer you need to wait. Awaiting Reviewer Selection, which is the next stage, means that the editor has received responses from multiple peer reviewers and is presently in the process of making a selection among them. Answer: The status “reviewers assigned” indicates that the reviewers accepted the invitation to review your paper. Feb 18, 2022 · Awaiting Reviewer Selection. If there is a refusal on the invitations, the Jun 26, 2020 · 1. Now for the last 12 days its status is "awaiting recommendations". Feb 28, 2021 · My paper underwent a revision. 29 submitted 5. 一旦审稿人被分配，他们将开始对您的论文进行详细评审。. Feb 27, 2021 · Awaiting Reviewer Scores means that your paper is being peer reviewed. Aug 9, 2022 · After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. This page is also available within the submission by clicking the “Manuscript Information” tab. 岳麓山摸鱼大师 2022-10-09. Reviews can be returned to the editor within a few days, or it may take a couple of weeks depending on the journal. May 6, 2021 · Does it mean your paper will go through another round of review? Not necessarily. Sep 11, 2017 · 1 Answer to this question. You may or may not learn anything. After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. As shown in this question on the process for journals , that initial "processing" step usually involves an initial assessment by that initial editor, and if it passes that hurdle it will Aug 3, 2021 · Dear Team, First, thank you for running such a stunning forum. This change has occurred Aug 13, 2015 · Since then it has been 4 months and the paper is still 'awaiting reviewer invitation'. But it could also have other outcomes, including requesting revision. ’ It's been one month since this change happened and there is no update. The day after the submission though, the two statuses of ‘Awaiting Final Decision’ and ‘Awaiting Reviewer Decision’ were displayed together. Nov 2, 2020 · Status stuck at Awaiting Editor Assignment. Aug 9, 2023 · 5. (The journal I submitted to allows it to be reprinted by Also known as: with reviewers, with referees, under review, awaiting referee assignment, awaiting referee reports, awaiting reviewer scores, awaiting reviewer invitation , reviewers assigned, manuscript assigned to peer-reviewer/s (NPG) The initial selection of referees is usually comprised in the previous step. What does this mean? Was the manuscript reviewed? I think the status should have changed to something like Awaiting Reviewer Scores before Awaiting EIC Decision. They will be responsible for evaluating the manuscript and checking that its scope matches with that of the journal. I for example look at my assignments once a week. Also, ‘SAE’ perhaps stands for ‘Specialist Associate Editor. Going by that assumption, the status of your first manuscript "ED: Not Assigned, GE: Not Assigned, Awaiting JM Checklist" means that no action has yet been taken on your paper. Mar 5, 2019 · In short, the switching of the status repeatedly from “awaiting reviewer selection” to “awaiting reviewer assignment” and back implies that the editor is having a hard time finding reviewers for your paper. One possibility is that since there was a delay in the review, the paper was sent to a different reviewer without waiting too long for the overdue review. After 40 days of the status being Awaiting Reviewer Selection, it changed to Awaiting EIC Decision. " Then it was assigned to an Editorial Assistant (EA) for admin check. Thus, seemingly, the review process ended only for a second one to be initiated by the EA just days later. I took this to mean that the paper has passed the desk review, since the editor is selecting reviewers. 27 Revise and Resubmit Translation: 4. Answer: This means that your manuscript has not yet been assigned to a reviewer. Sep 5, 2022 · Awaiting Reviewer Assignment means the journal editor has started reaching out to potential reviewers for your manuscript. I find "awaiting reviewer invitation" to be a slightly strange phrase, but taken at face value it seems to mean that they still have not even asked anyone to referee the paper, let alone found a referee, let alone gotten the report back from a referee! 1. "Awaiting reviewer invitation" should strictly be a very brief status, since the time between the editor deciding to invite reviewers and the editor actually inviting reviewers should be very brief, on the order of a few minutes. Just give it some time; either you will get a decision or it will go for the review process. Apr 26, 2023 · Awaiting AE Assignment状态的持续时间一般1-3天左右。 (4)Awaiting Reviewer Assignment: 当稿件被SE分配到了某一AE后，状态变为under review，AE开始邀请审稿人之后，稿件状态立刻变为Awaiting Reviewer Assignment. We hope that the journal can be managed well. The journal may create your account and e-mail you instructions on how to login. Feb 15, 2023 · As an editor, I can tell you getting a reviewer let alone a competent reviewer is difficult. Poloz 2023-05-29. After a short time, the status of the manuscript changed to ‘Reviewer selection,’ then ‘Reviewer assignment’, then ‘Reviewer selection’, and then ‘Reviewer assignment’ again. Jul 10, 2024 · External review process. Dear Bilal Ahmad The status 'Awaiting AE Recommendation' means that, based on the peer reviewer (or technical editor review, in this case), the AE is making a decision on the paper. I sent two emails about updating the status of the paper to editor and Editor-in-Chief several days ago and I got no reply from them. Apr 23, 2020 · Because ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ means that the manuscript passed the admin and/or Associate Editor (AE) check and was awaiting peer review. The Awaiting CE/Reviewer Scores status also means that the AE has assigned the basic number of peer reviewers required for Sep 17, 2019 · Most online systems give authors the opportunity to check on the status of submissions: it’s a good idea to log in regularly to make sure that your article is moving through the peer review process. Even yesterday the status was still "awaiting reviewer selection", but today it was changed to "awaiting EIC decision". 19 Under review 6. The status, "Awaiting Decision" means that the manuscript is being processed. Nov 21, 2022 · After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. So, why has it returned to the referee(s) after last week's status? Nov 21, 2016 · Four months seems unreasonable. Feb 26, 2021. Last week, the status changed to Awaiting AE Recommendation. Sep 14, 2019 · However, in this case, “Under Review” means that the paper was picked up for an initial review of the quality of the paper and of a match with the journal’s scope. But the editor has sent your manuscript to another reviewer that's why it's again "awaiting Mar 29, 2018 · 0. ""Awaiting AE recommendation" status means that the AE has collected all reviews from the reviewers who were assigned to review your manuscript and that the AE's decision for acceptance is pending. Nov 2, 2018 · However, if the status is “Awaiting reader selection,” it would mean something completely different. Interestingly, it is/was awaiting "reviewer" (not reviewers- in a plural form) recommendations. Thus the subsequent status “under review” means that the manuscript has been sent out for review. Either the AE is on leave or having a holiday trip with family or health issues. The status is still "awaiting assignment" and I checked the online system which shows that even no editor has been assigned to my paper. As you've mentioned, you have addressed the previous reviewer's concerns, so the EIC may suggest moving the manuscript to peer After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. Don't make assumptions. Further, an editor may not carry out his/her duties every day. 这是一个重要的环节，因为审稿人的 We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The status of the paper changed several times. This is the first stage of the peer-review process and your manuscript will be here until the assigned Editor has selected some suitable experts to invite to review. However, the change of status back to “reviewers assigned” indicates that at least one of the Jan 31, 2024 · Feb 26, 2021 · Awaiting Reviewer Assignment means the journal editor has started reaching out to potential reviewers for your manuscript. 11 Awaiting Associate Editor Assignment 6. I know some editors do it once a month or every K months. In case of major revisions, revised manuscripts are almost always sent for a second round of peer review. I submitted a short paper to a math journal more that one month ago. This change has occurred Mar 22, 2021 · Yes, it’s a reasonable ask to write to the editor requesting an update on the manuscript, and they should be okay with responding to you in case they have an update. This may involve checking that the submission is within the journal's scope and adheres to submission guidelines. fk em gr ge kf fn jx ww gn lf