Pfsense gateway monitoring ip Status/Routing/Gateways shows correct new IPs as a Gateway and as Monitor IP 3. The same solution works well : "This option's been added to the gateway advanced settings. supercm; Jr. If they do not, verify that a proper monitor IP address is used as discussed in Gateway Settings. If the gateway has a I would like to know how the "Monitor IP" option under SYSTEM > GATEWAYS > EDIT GATEWAY menu works. Member; Posts 52; Logged; Re: Gateway Monitoring. My problem was gone and I could then see the right routes to the DNS servers and gateway monitoring IPs. 4, gateway ISP2. pfSense default behavior to check if a gateway is up is to simply ping the gateway. Here is a list with some of the most important facts about our So unless you run a multi-wan setup (no info given) it may be very hard for the interface to send out any mail regardless. 9. You cannot have multiple routes for the same destination IP address active at the same time. in Diagnostics/Packet Capture I can capture my ICMP requests/replies. After setting the gateway group. And if i try to execute a diagnostic ping from pfSense to an external ip address using the new wan interface, I get a very beautiful "Dest unreachable". jimp Rebel Alliance Developer Netgate. Reply reply N0_Klu3 On the WAN side things are the same, except with public IPs. Summary. 22. 3. From what I understand, if nothing is defined in the "Monitor IP" MultiWAN - Recommended Gateway ICMP "Monitor IP" address? I have pfSense appliances with multiWAN implemented and am finding that using Google 8. (adding yet another reason for people to choose OPNSense) and it would help to be able to monitor both the gateway IP and the remote IP to find where the packet loss is actually happening. yes, make sure the same IPs go out the same ISPs. Check. A default gateway can now be a part of a group. DNS servers: 8. 5/24, which often have gateway IP addresses in another subnet because they are When pings spike to 40ms, I have the second gateway take over new connections. the next hop), is local to the site and not on the other end of an Internet or remote connection. With the Domotz pfSense monitor, you can proactively monitor your pfSense gateway, underlying FreeBSD server, and more. Diagnostics/Ping I can ping new remote IP with IPsec Vti as a Source (and I see new IP as a Source) 5. 1 route: writing to routing socket: Address already in use delete host 10. 113. 4, users can specify in a group which gateway to use first, second, third, etc. Setting an IP address as a monitor IP address adds a static route in the OS routing table so the traffic leaves via the proper interface and gateway. 8 2nd gateway has monitor ip 8. THE PROBLEM: when i put an external monitor ip on a new gateway, i get an "offline" status on that interface. The status output includes the gateway name, gateway IP, Monitor IP, status and Alternative Monitor IP: An address to ping via this gateway instead of the gateway itself. Enabling this checkbox overrides that behavior. 56, and a default gateway of 203. When pings drop below threshold, that gateway is used again. 168. Would be my first time making an entry here so if it's not within the rules bear with me thanks. 8 is the secondary (Tier 2) internet connection an added bonus (imho) would be having something useful that has been requested in the pfsense community for years without results. 8, gateway ISP1 8. System>Routing, edit your gateway, specify something > 0 in the "Data Payload" field. So I don’t monitor my internet from within pfsense, but I have a Telegraf/Influx/Grafana stack recording all my metrics about my network. route delete 10. I just have some trouble understanding why such a rudementary feature like WAN uplink monitoring is implemented so poorly. 8 as a gateway monitor but it occasionally went down and I lost internet (though internet was up, 8. If you just want to track short outages, fine, if your mail server is behind the gateway, fine, but if you expect an email on your phone, ie. For example: WAN1 interface status shows link up with the IP. 1 is the primary (Tier 1) internet connection - WAN2 interface with monitor IP 8. Thus pfSense is trying to ping 203. 8 was down). For example: My philosophy is to monitor my services separately from the service . 1. Each gateway must have a unique Monitor IP address. J. Created new gateway with monitor ip 8. 1, then I can ping 8. Not all Gateways respond to ICMP request so this gets around that issue. the gateways of those WAN interfaces configured with monitor IPs 1. Also improved is gateway monitoring. Mainly because it can create a situation where DNS is completely broken due to a common configuration e. 8 is the secondary (Tier 2) internet connection I have a cable isp. newwanip: pfSense package system has detected an IP change or dynamic WAN reconnection - 10. Oct 8 01:11:34 php-fpm 36202 /rc Started to see this issue today and I am unsure what is causing it. 13 -> 10. When you defined a gateway on the IP alias subnet, apinger is configured to monitor it using the main interface IP address. The default gateway switches back Set the monitor IP on each gateway Create a gateway group Tier1 Tier2 Set Gateway group as default gateway at System=>Routing. 8) is not pingable from my pfSense box and as a result, the gateway is considered as being down. # opnsense-patch 02dc1ebd93 And then reboot. With version 2. The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and routing platform based on FreeBSD. 13 - Restarting packages. Related to this, I just discovered that you can't set your monitoring IP to the gateway IP. 1_5_amd64 (latest) and when i switch on dual gateway, the gateways status is offline. In previous pfSense versions default gateway switching didn’t have any particular order, and users didn’t have control over which gateways were picked upon outage. e. This idles between 10-30ms and spikes to 70ms under load. 1. Slightly higher metric, one weight higher. BUT 1. For example, if a firewall has an IP address of 192. 8 and 8. In some (I would argue most) cases, it's preferable that these static routes not be created. Switched on OPT1 interface to (dhcp) mode 2. 8 - a gateway group configured for failover - that gateway group set as default gateway - WAN1 interface with monitor IP 1. One such scenario is when you have 2 IP addresses on an Interface (a main IP address and an IP Alias). g 8. The status of a gateway as perceived by the firewall can be checked by visiting Status > Gateways or by using the Gateway: The IP address of the gateway. Gateway monitor shows pending/unknown. Default gateway fails to switch back to main, and obviously nothing else after that happens either. Creating a WAN Failure¶ There are a number of ways to simulate a WAN failure. So, I did a traceroute and chose a cable router close to home. The RTT and Loss figures on the Gateways widget are for ping responses to the gateway monitor IP, which often is different to the gateway IP. By default the firewall adds static routes for gateway monitor IP addresses to ensure traffic to the monitor IP address leaves via the correct interface. OPNsense seems still a little bit unpolished, so I’m already decided that pfSense is the way to go. If the gateway is local, such as one directly on a CPE or modem, then pinging a remote address In some cases pfsense does not configure the correct source ip address for apinger checks. Whatever IP I use for gateway monitoring (e. Status/Gateways still shows 'old This has been covered multiple times in multiple similar tickets. 1). 0. If you try to revert the default gateway option back you'll need to up/down the interface to restore the static route and sometimes it requires a reboot. Quote from: chemlud on January 01, 2023, 10:04:52 PM You should configure the monitoring IP under System -> Gateways -> Single (e. Route table prior. This is needed to The most common scenario is when a gateway, (i. 8. I repeat similar here for 3rd gateway, which is a 4G link and ultimately last resort only. Currently, static routes are added for each gateway monitor IP, to force dpinger ICMP to leave via the given interface. I can go into System > Routing > Click Save/Apply (no changes), and that seems to kick the gateway monitor. It would be nice to be able to choose to display gateway IP, monitor IP or both on the widget. Modified LAN Rule System Monitoring¶ pfSense® software provides a wealth of information about the state of the firewall, Using an Alternate Monitor IP Address for Gateway Monitoring; CARP Status; Interface Status; Viewing Active Network Sockets; Services Status and In some cases pfsense does not configure the correct source ip address for apinger checks. The “ping” input plugin will ping First, navigate to Status > Gateways and ensure all WAN gateways are show as Online under Status, as well as on the Gateway Groups tab. 1 pfSense monitor's each WAN connection by pinging the monitor address you specify. Status/IPsec shows that IPsec is UP and running 4. x this worked fine with specifying a monitoring IP. RAM Disk Settings¶ ISP1 gateway - monitor IP 8. Something similar to the aliases where we click on the + button and we are adding (but here I assume that here can and should have a limit). Our pfSense Monitoring Tool. Members Online • javi404 Is there a way to change the gateway monitoring to ping the IP at another interval instead of 1 second. 1 is the primary (Tier 1) internet connection; WAN2 interface with monitor IP 8. 4 3. Developed and maintained by Netgate®. pfSense was monitoring either gateway IP (local IP), or Internet IP, but monitoring was always showing 100% lost packets. The form accepts it but going back to edit the gateway shows an empty monitoring IP field. . networks a gateway resides in the same subnet as one of the interfaces on a host. Your router might have public IP 203. To use an alternate address, do as follows: In the pfSense® webGUI, Status > Gateways displays the current status of all configured gateways. Monitor: The IP address being used by the gateway monitoring system to determine the status of the gateway. 1 fib 0: gateway uses the same route In 2. 6. Hello, i am running on pfsense 2. My workaround for now is to not specify a monitoring IP for my OVPN gateways. So currently I’m heavily evaluating pfSense and OPNsense. 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0. 4 have been I guess, your pfsense gateway is a LAN address of your ISP router? In Options for Gateways of pfsense, try to change Monitor Address to a pingable IP outside your local network (ex. 05 there was no issue with default gateway group also. I have the following un-checked: ☐Disable Gateway Monitoring ☐Disable Gateway Monitoring Action I was using 8. 1 and 8. 8 ISP2 gateway - monitor IP 8. 8 (from the pfSense command line) but now 1. 4. The pfSense Documentation. last edited by . 8 being used as a I would like to request that it be possible to add more than one ip to monitor the gateway (s), today we have the possibility to use only one. 1 is not pingable. 2. NOTE: This allows pfSense to make sure the WAN_PPPOE connection is up. If the ping fails, the link is marked down and the appropriate filover configuration is used (actually if the Monitor IP: 9. If I change the monitor IP to 1. WAN1 + WAN2, with 8. when the interface is down for an hour for you to fix the issue, that's not going to happen on a WAN that is SPOF as You can run this, in command line, in your pfsense to add this patch if you want to have it before the next release. On 22. - the gateways of those WAN interfaces configured with monitor IPs 1. - when non-default gateway's interface went Down, pfSense stopped sending ICMP requests for non-default gateway's Monitoring IP - when non-default gateway's interface went UP, pfSense immediately started to send ICMP requests and /Status/Gateway showed that non-default gateway was ONLINE. g. You can only monitor one public IP per WAN. Created new gateway group where is Gate1 and Gate2 in Tier1-Tier1 4. In Options for Gateways of pfsense, try to change Monitor Address to a pingable IP outside your local network (ex. 8; a gateway group configured for failover; that gateway group set as default gateway; WAN1 interface with monitor IP 1. When this option is set, the user will have to ensure the traffic exits the correct interface in some other way. The end. Thank you very much in advance ! @stephenw10 Yep if i remove the IP from the gateway monitor adress and allow it to ping the gateway ip it does the same Oct 8 01:11:36 php-fpm 36202 /rc. 9). 1 or 9. twebe qagqql xtvtii stpa dcbmrwy cgwr lqnm jabv ylayz ldiakhtp